Why Following a Method Exactly Is Usually How It Fails

Picture of Dr Lisa Turner

Dr Lisa Turner

World renowned visionary, author, high-performance mindset trainer for coaches to elevate skills, empower clients to achieve their maximum potential

Give a practitioner a clean framework with clear rules and they will follow it precisely, which

is very often the exact moment it stops working. This is one of the least discussed problems in

professional practice, and it becomes more pressing every year that we get better at writing

frameworks down.

Here is the smallest possible example. Air puts out a candle. Air also fans a bonfire. If your

rule is “add air to reduce fire”, you will be right often enough to trust the rule, and then one

day you will add air to something smouldering and produce a considerably larger fire than the

one you were trying to manage.

The rule was not wrong. It was incomplete in a way that only shows up in application.

A framework is a compression. Somebody with years of accumulated judgement writes down the

regularities they have noticed, because the regularities are the transmissible part. What cannot

be compressed is the constant micro-assessment that tells them when the regularity does not

apply, because that assessment is running on information specific to the moment.

So the document that gets handed over contains the pattern and omits the exception-handling,

and the person receiving it has no way of knowing what was left out. They are not being misled.

They have been given the most transferable version of something whose most valuable part is not

very transferable at all.

This is why so many well-trained practitioners are technically correct and ineffective. They are

applying an accurate model to a situation it does not fit, and the model gives them no signal

that this is happening.

Watch anybody genuinely skilled at an intervention and you will see the same pattern regardless

of discipline. They apply a small amount. They observe what happened. They adjust.

That loop is the competence. Not the size of the intervention and not the elegance of the model,

but the rate at which they check reality and correct. An experienced practitioner running a

crude model with a tight feedback loop will outperform a novice running an excellent model

without one, every time.

The consequence for anybody learning is uncomfortable. The framework you were taught is the

scaffolding, not the building. It gets you to the point where you can start observing usefully.

The years after that are spent finding out where it does not apply, which is knowledge you can

only acquire by being wrong in specific, correctable ways.

Small interventions become the default

If you know the model is incomplete, you stop making large moves based on it. You do the

smallest version, see what happened, and go again. This is slower per step and dramatically

faster overall, because the alternative is a large confident intervention followed by an

expensive correction.

Being wrong becomes information rather than failure

A practitioner who expects the model to be right experiences a mismatch as a personal or

professional failure. A practitioner who expects the model to be incomplete experiences the same

mismatch as the most valuable thing that happened all week, because that is where the

exception-handling gets built.

You get more careful about what you teach

Anybody writing up their own methodology should be uneasy about how confident it reads. The

document will be applied by people without your judgement, and the cleaner it looks the more

mechanically it will be followed. Some of the best practitioner documents I have seen include

explicit notes on where the model breaks, which is rare and worth copying.

Everybody wants the table. The table is genuinely useful and it is where you have to start,

because you cannot observe intelligently without a frame to observe against.

But the table is not the skill. The skill is the loop, and the loop is unglamorous, slow to

build, and almost impossible to sell, which is presumably why so much training stops at the

table and calls it a qualification.

If a method appears to work every time you apply it, the most likely explanation is not that

you have found an exceptional method. It is that nobody is checking closely.

Share:

Related Posts

What to Do When You Feel Stuck

When somebody has been stuck for months, the explanations that arrive are almost always about their character. They lack discipline. They are avoiding something. They

Consent Management Platform by Real Cookie Banner